The Math Says Keep Your 2.6% Mortgage Forever—So Why Are So Many Investors Racing to Pay It Off?

Benzinga and Yahoo Finance LLC may earn commission or revenue on some items through the links below.

A heated debate is splitting one of investing’s most level-headed communities, and it has nothing to do with stock picking or market timing. On r/Bogleheads—the forum dedicated to passive investing pioneer Jack Bogle’s principles—members are wrestling with a question that pits cold financial logic against something far less quantifiable: peace of mind.

The issue? Whether to pay off ultra-low-rate mortgages locked in during the pandemic era, even when the math screams that it’s the wrong move.

When 2.6% Feels Like a Gift—And a Burden

The financial calculus is straightforward enough to sketch on a napkin. With a 2.6% mortgage rate—what forum members are calling “cheeeeeeap money” and a “once in many generations” opportunity—the arbitrage argument is overwhelming.

Don't Miss:

Accredited Investors Can Now Tap Into the $36 Trillion Home Equity Market — Without Buying a Single Property Arrived Home's Private Credit Fund’s has historically paid an annualized dividend yield of 8.1%*, which provides access to a pool of short-term loans backed by residential real estate with just a $100 minimum.

According to discussions on r/Bogleheads, U.S. Treasuries currently yield around 4%, while high-yield savings accounts and money market funds are paying north of 4.3%. That’s a guaranteed positive spread of roughly 1.4 to 1.7 percentage points with zero additional risk. Even after accounting for the declining mortgage interest deduction – less than 10% of Americans itemize deductions anymore –, the numbers favor keeping the debt.

Add in inflation running higher than 2.6%, and the real cost of that mortgage shrinks every year. One user put it bluntly: “Your house is literally getting cheaper for you to own.”

The mathematical consensus: invest extra cash at higher returns, maintain liquidity for emergencies, and let the arbitrage work in your favor. A thousand dollars per month invested at 8% instead of thrown at mortgage principal could pay off the entire remaining balance years earlier—and leave substantial capital left over.

Trending: Have $100k+ to invest? Charlie Munger says that's the toughest milestone — don't stall now. Get matched with a fiduciary advisor and keep building

But Personal Finance Isn’t Just Math

Yet a significant contingent of forum members who paid off mortgages with rates between 2.8% and 3.5% report feeling “exceptionally happy” and experiencing “immense freedom,” according to r/Bogleheads. Several described the decision as “priceless,” explicitly acknowledging they left money on the table.

Story Continues

One member noted that during the COVID-19 pandemic, they were grateful their house was paid off. Another pointed out that eliminating the mortgage payment dramatically improves retirement cash flow and provides mental comfort that no spreadsheet can capture.

The divide reflects what behavioral economists call the “maximizer versus satisficer” split. Maximizers optimize for the highest possible return; satisficers optimize for adequate security and emotional well-being.

The Retirement Planning Wrinkle

For those pursuing early retirement, the decision becomes more complex. Monthly mortgage payments must be drawn from investment portfolios, creating taxable income. According to r/Bogleheads discussions, these withdrawals can trigger adverse consequences: exceeding income limits for Affordable Care Act health insurance subsidies – the 400% federal poverty level threshold – or incurring Medicare IRMAA surcharges later in life.

See Also: Backed by $300M+ in Assets and Microsoft's Climate Fund, Farmland LP Opens Vital Farmland III to Accredited Investors

Paying off the mortgage eliminates this required taxable cash flow entirely. For someone already sitting on $5 million in liquid assets planning to retire early, the mathematical “loss” of a 1.4% arbitrage opportunity may pale against the strategic benefit of reducing taxable income needs.

The Framework: Choose Your Optimization

The r/Bogleheads community ultimately frames this as a personal priority decision rather than a universal truth. The calculated solution is clear: invest extra cash in vehicles earning more than your mortgage rate and maintain full liquidity.

The personal solution? If debt-free status provides profound emotional benefit and you’re already financially insulated, paying it off is acceptable—even if “mathematically suboptimal.”

As one forum member summarized: “It all depends on you and your individual needs.”

In a community built on evidence-based investing and rational decision-making, the mortgage debate reveals something Bogle himself understood: sometimes the best financial plan is the one you’ll actually stick with, even if a spreadsheet says otherwise.

Read Next: Maximize saving for your retirement and cut down on taxes: Schedule your free call with a financial advisor to start your financial journey – no cost, no obligation.

Image: Shutterstock

This article The Math Says Keep Your 2.6% Mortgage Forever—So Why Are So Many Investors Racing to Pay It Off? originally appeared on Benzinga.com

View Comments