Murphy USA Inc (MUSA) Q3 2025 Earnings Call Highlights: Resilient Performance Amidst Fuel ...

This article first appeared on GuruFocus.

EBITDA: $285 million, flat compared to the prior year despite lower fuel margins. Fuel Margins: All-in margins of $0.307 per gallon, with retail margins at $0.283. Fuel Volume: Average per store month volumes down 1.8% in Q3. Merchandise Contribution: Up $24.4 million or 11.2% in Q3. Nicotine Categories Growth: Over 20% increase driven by strong promotional activity. Center Store Categories Growth: Approximately 5% increase. Same-Store Food and Beverage Sales Growth: QuickChek reported fourth successive quarter of growth. Operating Expenses: Per store operating expense up 2.8% in Q3. New Store Openings: Projected to be over 45 for the year, with nearly 40 stores under construction. Share Repurchase Program: New $2 billion authorization through 2030. Dividend Increase: 10% annual growth, with a $0.63 per share dividend payable on December 1. 2025 Fuel Volume Guidance: Adjusted to 235,000 to 237,000 gallons per store per month. 2025 Merchandise Contribution Guidance: Tightened to $870 million to $875 million. 2025 SG&A Guidance: Adjusted to $230 million to $240 million. Effective Tax Rate: Expected to be between 23.5% to 24.5% for the full year. Adjusted EBITDA Guidance: Approximately $1 billion for full year 2025.

Warning! GuruFocus has detected 4 Warning Signs with FFWM. Is MUSA fairly valued? Test your thesis with our free DCF calculator.

Release Date: October 30, 2025

For the complete transcript of the earnings call, please refer to the full earnings call transcript.

Positive Points

Murphy USA Inc (NYSE:MUSA) announced a new $2 billion share repurchase program, signaling strong capital allocation strategy and commitment to returning value to shareholders. The company reported third-quarter EBITDA of $285 million, maintaining the same level as the previous year despite lower fuel margins, showcasing operational resilience. Merchandise contribution dollars increased by 11.2% in Q3, driven by strong promotional activity, particularly in nicotine categories. Murphy USA Inc (NYSE:MUSA) plans to open over 45 new stores in 2025, with a pipeline supporting 50-plus stores in 2026, indicating robust growth prospects. The company has successfully implemented cost-saving initiatives, resulting in lower operating expenses and SG&A costs, enhancing overall efficiency.

Negative Points

Fuel volumes are expected to come in below the low end of the original guidance range for 2025, reflecting challenges in the current low price environment. Despite strong merchandise performance, the low price and low volatility environment for fuel margins remain a challenge, impacting overall profitability. The company faces competitive pressures in key markets, which may require continued investment in pricing strategies to maintain market share. Murphy USA Inc (NYSE:MUSA) has adjusted its full-year fuel volume guidance downward, indicating ongoing challenges in achieving expected sales volumes. The transition in leadership with the CEO's retirement may introduce uncertainties, although continuity plans are in place.

Story Continues

Q & A Highlights

Q: Can you provide insights on the fuel margins and the impact of recent price changes? A: Mindy K. West, President and COO, explained that October saw a brief spike in margins due to a run-up in prices, which normalized by the end of the month. The low price environment means customers are less price-sensitive, impacting volumes. Despite this, fuel margins remain strong at $0.30 all-in, showcasing the structural component's resilience.

Q: How did the ZYN promotion impact your merchandise performance, and do you expect similar promotions in the future? A: Mindy K. West highlighted that the ZYN promotion was significant, showcasing Murphy USA's execution capabilities. The promotion drove traffic and increased awareness in the nicotine category. The company expects continued promotional opportunities as manufacturers invest in reduced-risk products, leveraging Murphy USA's strong customer base and promotional effectiveness.

Q: With the recent increase in dividends and share repurchase authorization, how should we view your capital allocation strategy relative to growth? A: R. Andrew Clyde, CEO, emphasized the commitment to a balanced 50-50 capital allocation strategy, supporting both growth and shareholder returns. The dividend increase aims to reward long-term shareholders, while the share repurchase program reflects confidence in future cash flow generation, even as the company accelerates new store growth.

Q: How has your experience in various roles prepared you for the CEO position? A: Mindy K. West discussed her extensive background, including roles as CFO and COO, which provided her with a deep understanding of financial discipline, commercial aspects, and customer engagement. This experience has equipped her to lead Murphy USA effectively, balancing growth with maintaining a resilient balance sheet.

Q: What opportunities do you see for cost optimization in the coming years? A: Mindy K. West noted that while the recent restructuring was a significant one-time cost reduction, the company will continue to optimize operations. Opportunities for automation, resource consolidation, and workflow streamlining are being explored to maintain efficiency and control costs, especially in a challenging fuel environment.

For the complete transcript of the earnings call, please refer to the full earnings call transcript.

View Comments